24 April 2006 · Committee
Prasline, Grenaby Road, Ballabeg, Castletown, Isle Of Man, IM9 4hd
The proposal was a resubmission of an earlier refused application. It involved extending the existing rectangular bungalow (approximately 16 x 9m) with a new 17-metre wing set at right-angles to the western gable, providing a living room, hall/dining room, kitchen, utility, and a converted garage bedroom, with under-building storage at the southern end. The property sits in open countryside near Ballabeg and is subject to an agricultural worker occupancy condition. While the officer considered the landscape impact comparatively limited — noting the extension would be no higher than the existing building and that hipped roofs and stonework plinths would help — the decisive concern was that the combined size and nature of the dwelling would make it unsuitable for agricultural worker occupation, both in terms of its scale and its likely value. The Planning Committee refused the application on that ground, in line with the officer's recommendation.
The enlarged building would be too large and too valuable to function appropriately under the existing occupancy condition.
Refusal Reasons
Planning Circular 1/88
paragraph 9
O THE VILLAGE SHALL CONTINUE TO BE PROTECTED FROM UNSYMPATHETIC DEVELOPMENT BY THE DESIGNATION OF THE AREA AS HIGH LANDSCAPE VALUE AND SCENIC SIGNIFICANCE AND BY THE APPLICATION OF PLANNING CIRCULARS 1/88, 3/88 AND 3/89 AND BY THE CONSIDERATION OF THE RELEVANT SECTOR PLANS B & E (PLANNING CIRCULARS 10/91 AND 11/91 RESPECTIVELY).
Housing Policy 16
emerging Strategic Plan
ovide special opportunities for the study of matters relating to these interests. This Plan does not propose any specific Proposals at this time. Areas subject to flooding and erosion In 2016, the National Strategy on Sea Defences, Flooding and Coastal Erosion Evidence Report was published10. It identified areas at risk of fluvial, surface water and coastal flooding and coastal erosion now and in the future taking into account climate change, economic growth and development and population growth. The Evidence Report included a comprehensive Risk Assessment to assess the impacts of coastal, fluvial and surface water flooding and coastal erosion on key economic, infrastructure, environmental and social receptors. Within the Eastern area, Douglas (comprising Douglas Bay, Douglas Harbour, Glass/Douglas/Dhoo/Middle River Confluence, River Glass and Upper Dhoo) and Laxey were identified as being at high risk both now and in the future and requir e urgent consideration, further investigation and potential intervention to reduce the evident risk. Flooding can threaten life and cause damage to property and public infrastructure and it is essential that the Isle of Man builds its economic, environmental and social resilience with regard to flooding. The effects of weather events can be increased by decisions about the location, design, and nature of development, and may be affected by future climate chan ge. Consideration of flood risk has therefore formed an integral part of both the process of allocating land for development in the Area Plan for East, with flood risk acting as a 'critical constraint' in the Site Assessment Framework used to assess proposed sites. 10 National Strategy on Sea Defences, Flooding and Coastal Erosion 2016, GD No. 2016/0044 Flood Risk Maps have been produced by the MUA and the data contained therein has been used to identify Flood Risk Areas in the plan area. The risk areas shown relate to tidal flooding and fluvial flooding. The fluvial flooding maps illustrate a 100 year return period and for tidal a 200 year return period. Land outside of these areas is considered to be at low risk of flooding from main rivers and the sea, although it may be at risk from other sources such as surface water and groundwater flooding. Natural Environment Recommendation 3 The Department supports further consideration and investigation of the impacts of coastal, fluvial and surface water flooding and coastal erosion on key economic, infrastructure, environmental and social receptors. The ongoing work of the Flooding Advisory Group is recognised as part of this, as well as the findings and recommendations set out in the Laxey Flood Independent Review Report. 11 The following, including the areas of Douglas (comprising Douglas Bay, Douglas Harbour, Glass/Douglas/Dhoo/Middle River Confluence, River Glass and Upper Dhoo) and Laxey, are all identified as being at high risk both now and in the future. 11 The Laxey Flood of 1st October 2019 took place during the Public Inquiry. The Independent Review Report was published on 29th May 2020 and is available on the Isle of Man Government Website https://www.gov.im/ The Urban Environment Introduction Our towns and villages should be places t hat bind communities together. Placemaking is driven by making the most of existing urban fabric, maintaining it well and making incremental improvements. A high quality urban environment contributes to a good quality of life and encourages walking, cycling and public transport as instinctive and attractive options. Good quality urban areas are designed, built and maintained on the principle that people come first. Urban places in the East The urban environment of the East is diverse and represents a multi-layering of the Island's past, present and future. All of the East's settlements compare favourably with those of neighbouring nations in terms of safety and in general quality of life is perceived as being high, reflective in many ways of the close proximity of our urban areas to the great outdoors. High quality Georgian and Victorian architecture shares space with the Manx vernacular and a range of twentieth century styles; covering a span of uses stretching from residential, to business premises, office spaces, shops, civic buildings and public realm. The urban environment faces significant challenges: the mixed quality and upkeep of much of the East's building stock can give an impression of a lack of unity in the built environment. Challenging topography, particularly in Douglas and Laxey, places a significant constraint on creating attractive, viable and usable places. Making space for residents, visitors, cars, public transport and bicycles in the built up Capital sets a challenge which needs addressing sooner rather than later. Growth in new employment sectors and changes in our working practices will have a significant impact on the demands we place on our u